Wireless screen-sharing technology is an easy and relatively inexpensive way to improve your ability to social distance in a meeting room – as well as switch from one presenter to another on a classroom display such as a projector or interactive touch display. The Qomo QConnect 1700 is a midrange priced product that enables any Windows or MacBook to wirelessly mirror their screen using WiFi technology and a third party application. So how does this compare to other wireless presentation systems such as the Barco ClickShare, and the BenQ InstaShow? We’ll look at three major questions most buyers ask when evaluating wireless HDMI systems.
The Qomo QConnect is a WiFi-based wireless presentation system where the system is designed to use your existing wireless network to share the video and audio from your computer. The main alternatives to this approach are button-based systems such as the Barco ClickShare and BenQ InstaShow, where a transmitter is plugged into the computer (or other devices) and can present with a single tap of a button.
The Qomo QConnect 1700 has a more complicated setup process and needs to be configured to the local wireless network and requires third-party software to be loaded onto your computer. New users must download either the “Utility for Windows” or “Utility for Mac” app, then, click and download the “MirrorOp (Sender)” application. You may need to disable some browser functions to download properly. Once you have everything configured, you are then instructed to create a USB “Token” that has essential login information and the applications needed to load onto a computer. You then configure the resolution of the HDMI or VGA port – up to 1080p.
To use the system, you must log in to the same network that the receiver is on and type in the receiver’s IP address from the standby screen. Once connected, you then download two different applications, and then enter a PIN to ensure you are broadcasting to the correct receiver. Unlike similar WiFi based products such as Airtame, Qomo does not disclose how much network bandwidth is used by the system, and there are warnings in the manual that network bandwidth limitations could impact performance
Because of their button-based architecture, these two are much simpler to setup. For the InstaShow, you simply plug in the receiver to the display (it auto-selects the resolution from the display) and then plug in the transmitter button to your device. There are no special applications or network configurations needed. According to the Commercial Integrator magazine review, the process took under three minutes. The Barco ClickShare is similar, although they require an app to be loaded onto your PC before use.
Both systems are simple to use – just plug in a button transmitter to the HDMI port on your computer – and it automatically connects. It takes about 10 seconds for an InstaShow button to set up an encrypted link (more about that in the next section) and start sharing your screen. No special apps or network logins are needed.
Fast, Easy & Worry-Free Wireless Presentation System BenQ InstaShow S
In 2019, there were over eight different security issues with different wireless presentation systems that enabled hackers to either bridge into a corporate network, shut down the network, or view confidential content being presented. How do these systems stack up?
The Qomo has several aspects that IT managers need to evaluate so they can be protected against security risks.
Because it uses a connection to your corporate or campus network to work, IT managers will need to ensure the device is properly secured so that the device cannot be used for unauthorized network access. The Qomo also has the risk of unauthorized users being able to view and record confidential presentations if encryption is not configured by the administrator. For a presenter, there is no way of knowing whether their presentation is protected or not. The Qomo system is not ISO27001 certified, and Qomo does not provide any additional documentation such as a security white paper.
Both the BenQ InstaShow and Barco ClickShare systems are highly secure. Both these systems encrypt all content coming from the transmitters and each company is ISO 27001 certified. IT managers can download detailed security white papers on either model for review by security experts to examine important details of how the units are protected. The BenQ InstaShow also has been certified against common threats by a third-party security company.
Both the Qomo QConnect and Barco ClickShare systems rely on software running on the presenter PC to mirror their screen onto the projector. This limits the support for the Qomo to common Windows and Mac PC’s and notebooks as the presentation devices that can use these apps. They can also be used with Android and iOS mobile devices as well when the proper app is loaded on these devices.
The BenQ InstaShow is unique in that it can connect with all the devices above – but also any HDMI enabled devices such as a Blu-ray player, digital camera, or digital signage media player. This can enable schools to use InstaShow buttons to wirelessly connect multiple digital microscopes in a lab to a central projector to view different student’s results. The InstaShow can also easily connect to any Chromebook via the HDMI output – just like a third party monitor.
While the Qomo has the lowest MSRP of the three units, it is more complicated to set up and use – and has security issues that need to be considered if confidential information such as budgets or salary information are ever going to be presented on the system. Both the BenQ and Barco systems are easier to set up than the Qomo and are highly secure against being used for unauthorized network access or content viewing. Of the three – the BenQ InstaShow can work with the largest number of devices due to its unique HDMI architecture. The InstaShow will also support HDCP content being wirelessly transmitted and can support four simultaneous presenters on the same screen.
|
BenQ InstaShow S |
Qomo QConnect 1700 |
Barco ClicksShare CS-200 |
---|---|---|---|
Ease of Setup & Use | BenQ InstaShow S Easiest – no app or network needed | Qomo QConnect 1700 Complex – requires apps and network | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 Easier – requires app |
Encryption | BenQ InstaShow S 128 bit on all transmissions | Qomo QConnect 1700 Optional | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 All transmissions encrypted |
Is Security White Paper available? | BenQ InstaShow S Yes | Qomo QConnect 1700 No | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 Yes |
Can Stream HDCP Content | BenQ InstaShow S Yes | Qomo QConnect 1700 No | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 Yes |
Device Support | BenQ InstaShow S Any device with HDMI output | Qomo QConnect 1700 Only Windows / Mac / iOS / Android | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 Only Windows / Mac / iOS / Android |
Maximum Resolution | BenQ InstaShow S 4K | Qomo QConnect 1700 1080p | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 1080p |
Max. Number of split screens | BenQ InstaShow S Four | Qomo QConnect 1700 Four | Barco ClicksShare CS-200 Two |
If you would like to either try out a BenQ InstaShow in your collaboration space or classroom, you can fill out a form and we will send you one to evaluate right in your own meeting room! Just click here to learn more about how you can test out an InstaShow and see if it is right for you. You can also call to talk to a wireless presentation expert at 888.818.5888 or connect via chat by clicking on the chatbox on the lower right on your screen so we can address your specific questions or arrange a demo.